System

Systematic Inbreeding

Pen

Kennel

Stud

Outcross

Random

Feral

Terminal Cross

Hybrids

Example

Laboratory strain

Smallholder's rare breed chickens

Dog breeder during world war

Alpaca breeder

Endangered breed to similar breed

Computer simulation

Animals in a large conservation park

Battery chicken farmer

Nursery breeding ornamental plants

Effective population size relative to actual population size

Very low -- ideally only half an individual!

variable depending on how many pens and breeders

variable depending on how many kennels

generally moderate

generally done as a last resort due to diminished genetic diversity beyond the point of recovery

high

high

very low

very low

Individual heterosis

NONE

MODERATE/POOR

MODERATE/POOR

MODERATE

MODERATE/GOOD

MODERATE/GOOD

MODERATE/GOOD

GOOD

GOOD

Population-wide diversity

NONE (or as close as possible)

HIGH

MODERATE/HIGH if enough groups maintained

MODERATE

MODERATE, if managed properly

MODERATE/HIGH depending on population size

MODERATE/HIGH depending on population size

LOW

LOW

Risk of outbreeding depression

LOW

LOW

LOW

LOW/MODERATE

MODERATE

MODERATE depending on size and distribution of starting gene pool

LOW/MODERATE

MODERATE/HIGH

HIGH

Greatest risk to genetic survival

Loss of line through genetic susceptibility to disease. Terminal inbreeding depression during creation of the strain

Gradual loss of small pockets of genetic diversity over time, overreliance on linebreeding and loss through inbreeding depression

Maintaining balance between overreliance on linebreeding and loss of genetic character through influx of outside genetic material

Popular sire syndrome (males of superb type become overrepresented in the breed and genetic diversity suffers or obscure genetic diseases become widespread)

Outbreeding depression, introduction of undesirable traits, loss of breed type

Generally resilient to genetic effects other than genetic drift

Generally resilient to genetic effects other than genetic drift and excessive selection, natural or otherwise

No breed as such and no genetic diversity; dependent on the survival of parent strains; specimens generally useless for further breeding

No breed as such and no genetic diversity; dependent on the survival of parent strains; specimens generally useless for further breeding and often biologically incapable of reproduction

Greatest strength

Genetically highly predictable

Excellent preservation of breed-wide genetic diversity in many small populations at the expense of individual heterosis

Good preservation of breed-wide genetic diversity in several moderate populations, but often at some expense to individual heterosis

Ability to improve rapidly on desired type and traits through access to highly selected males

Makes it possible to save a breed that has become genetically unviable, hopefully without compromising too much on the type and character of the breed

Used as a 'gold standard' model which other models can be compared against, but practically speaking does not exist

Allows animals to exhibit natural behaviour and choice of breeding partners; as close as possible to wild models

Creation of consistent animals that are able to survive in intensive farming situations to feed the masses

Creation of novelties, often because products cannot reproduce and are self-limiting, can prove lucrative to those who experiment with or discover hybrids